Disclaimer: The advice provided is for educational and informational purposes only. It is not a substitute for legal advice, psychological counseling, or law enforcement. Every situation is unique. The Other Way Martial Consulting assumes no liability for any actions taken based on this information.
Ask Sensei: Aware on the Commute, or Lost in Music?
Published on October 31, 2025
Sensei,
I live in a major city and commute daily via the subway and walking crowded sidewalks. My routine involves putting in noise-canceling headphones immediately upon leaving my building. I listen to podcasts or music while navigating the crowds.
Lately, I’ve had a few instances—people bumping into me hard, or feeling like someone was standing too close for too long on the train—that have made me uneasy. The issue is, I feel like my commute is the only time I have to myself, and I rely on my phone and audio to decompress and manage the stress of the city.
How am I supposed to stay safe and “aware” when the entire point of my commute is to tune out? Is it possible to find a middle ground?
— City Sleeper
Sensei’s Response:
City Sleeper,
This is one of the most common conflicts of modern life, and you are not alone in feeling it. You’re trying to balance two critical needs: the need for mental peace (decompression) and the need for physical safety (awareness). This is a common challenge for public transit safety. The “uneasy” feelings you’re getting are your instincts telling you that your current strategy is prioritizing one need at the expense of the other. The good news is that “awareness” and “decompression” are not mutually exclusive. A middle ground absolutely exists.
The problem with full noise-canceling headphones is that they eliminate your second-most-important sense for threat detection: your hearing. This lack of headphone awareness means you can’t hear footsteps approaching from behind, a change in someone’s tone of voice, or the commotion of a problem further down the subway car. You are asking your eyes to do 100% of the work, and as you’ve noticed, they can’t catch everything.
Let’s find that middle ground. The goal is to move from being a “soft target” (unaware) to a “hard target” (aware). We want to stay decompressed, but also know how to avoid looking like a target.
Strategy 1: Use “Transparency Mode” for Ambient Mode Safety
If your headphones have it, “Transparency” or “Ambient” mode is the single best technological solution. This feature is key to ambient mode safety. It uses microphones to actively pipe in the sound of the outside world, blending it with your audio. You can listen to your podcast at a low-to-medium volume while still hearing conversations, footsteps, and platform announcements perfectly. This is the “middle ground” you are looking for and one of the best subway safety tips for audio lovers. It allows you to “tune in” and “tune out” at the exact same time.
Strategy 2: The One-Ear-Out Rule for Headphone Awareness
If you don’t have transparency mode, the classic solution is the best one: one earbud in, one earbud out. This keeps one ear fully dedicated to situational awareness, boosting your headphone awareness. It may not be as immersive, but it is infinitely safer, especially for headphone walking safety, than being completely deaf to your surroundings. You can alternate ears to avoid fatigue. This simple act cuts your vulnerability in half.
Strategy 3: Compensate with Your Eyes to Avoid Looking Like a Target
Since your audio is distracting you, your visual awareness must compensate. This is non-negotiable if you want to avoid looking like a target. You can listen to your podcast, but you cannot be staring at your phone screen while walking or standing. Your head must be up and scanning.
On the sidewalk: Look ahead, note who is on the street, and check your corners before turning.
On the train: Don’t bury your face in your lap. Look at the reflections in the windows. This allows you to monitor the entire car, including who is standing “too close for too long,” without having to stare at them directly. Make brief, incidental eye contact. This signals, “I see you. I am aware.”
Strategy 4: Frame Your Music Awareness as Presence, Not Stress
You need to reframe what “awareness” means. Your “music awareness” doesn’t have to mean being a paranoid secret agent, stressed and scanning for threats. It simply means being present in your environment. It’s passively noticing things without judgment. “I notice a person in a red jacket just got on.” “I notice that group is loud.” “I notice this person has been standing near me for three stops.”
You may find that by being proactively aware (using transparency mode, keeping your head up), your subconscious stress actually decreases. Those “uneasy” feelings are your instincts screaming because they’re being starved of information. Give them that information, and they’ll quiet down, allowing you to truly decompress because you are in control of your environment, not just hiding from it.